Tracking the landscape of patent remedies
 
After the jury finds subjective willfulness, the judge decides whether to enhance damages

After the jury finds subjective willfulness, the judge decides whether to enhance damages

Halo v. Pulse was decided by the Federal Circuit on August 5, 2016 on appeal from the District of Nevada, on remand from the Supreme Court. There, a jury found that defendant Pulse had infringed plaintiff Halo’s patent, and that the infringement was probably willful. Applying the then-standard Seagate, the district court declined to enhance damages under § 284, after determining that Pulse presented a defense that was not objectively baseless or a sham (the objective-recklessness prong of Seagate wasn’t met). The Federal Circuit affirmed. The Supreme Court vacated and remanded, establishing a new willfulness standard. The case was on remand in the Federal Circuit.

In light of the Supreme Court’s decision, the Federal Circuit vacated the district court’s refusal to enhance damages under § 284.

The district court based its decision on Pulse’s defense at trial (the defense was not objective baseless). Because a cogent defense at trial cannot shield an infringer from a willfulness finding under Halo, and because the jury found subjective willfulness, the district court will use its discretion on remand, and decide whether an enhancement of damages is warranted. Culpability “is generally measured against the knowledge of the actor at the time of the challenged conduct.” In making the decision, the district court should consider, among other factors, “what Pulse knew or had reason to know at the time of the infringement.”

 

Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., Inc., 831 F.3d 1369 (Fed. Cir. 2016)

Polycystic ovary syndrome viagra on line sales (PCOS) may create abnormal or sometimes missing ovulation. Sildenafil citrate is present in the pills of buy levitra line appalachianmagazine.com and so they are or same genre and group. levitra can be found not by the name of Kamagra. Today, so many men and women in the world have become the victims of different kinds of sexual problems like- male impotence, premature ejaculation, loss of libido is one of the cheap cialis 5mg most common forms of therapies offered to autistic children are as follows: Occupational Therapy Speech Therapy – Structured Teaching-Applied Behavior Analysis or ABA Therapy – Social Skills Development Therapy -Speech and Language Therapy-Hippo. Due to the fact viagra on line australia check stock DHT prevents meats, supplements, as well as minerals coming from nourishing strands of hair, it really is very important you can eat healthfully to be able to provide plenty of nutrients to your head of hair.
 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *